Where to Find the Best Pizza on Martha's Vineyard

Martha's Vineyard isn't just a haven for beach-goers and summer vacationers; it's also a paradise for pizza lovers. Whether you crave a classic New York-style slice, a gourmet Italian creation, or something uniquely local, the island's pizzerias cater to every taste. Here’s your guide to the top pizza spots on Martha's Vineyard.

1. Giordano's Restaurant

Location: 18 Lake Avenue Oak Bluffs

A true landmark in Oak Bluffs, Giordano's has been delighting islanders and tourists alike since it first opened its doors. Known for their hearty Italian fare and robust pizzas, Giordano's serves up slices that are perfect after a day at the beach or before a night on the town. Their pizza is famous for its rich, flavorful sauce and generous toppings. Don't miss their vineyard specialty pizza. A must try!

2. Rocco's Pizzeria

Location: Tisbury Marketplace in downtown Vineyard Haven

Rocco's Pizzeria  offers a wide array of delectable dining options, not limited to their signature pizzas. Guests can indulge in an assortment of sandwiches, flavorful appetizers, fresh salads, refreshing sodas, hearty calzones, traditional pasta dishes, crunchy chips, and delightful desserts such as cannolis. Whether you're planning a relaxing evening at home, a lively dinner with friends by the beach, or seeking a satisfying late-night treat, pizza is the ultimate choice. At Roocco's Pizzeria, every meal is crafted with care and expertise, ensuring that each bite is as perfect as the last.

3. Porto Pizza

Location: Porto Pizza, 36 Water St, Vineyard Haven, MA 02568

Phone: (508) 693-6200

Porto Pizza has become a favorite among locals and tourists on the island, known for its exceptional pizza and service. Conveniently situated opposite the Steamship Authority and the Vineyard Haven Stop & Shop, it's easy to stop by. The restaurant features a newly renovated interior and exterior, providing a comfortable atmosphere along with stunning views of the Vineyard Haven harbor from its outdoor seating. Under new ownership since September 2019, Porto continues to offer its distinctive homemade recipes that give their pizzas a unique and delightful flavor. The menu includes homemade dough and sauce, a variety of toppings on different crusts including white or whole wheat, deep dish options, and specialty pizzas like the unique white pizza with tuna and onions. They also serve specialty slices, full pies in various sizes, and seasonal soups and salads for dine-in, takeaway, or delivery.

4. Edgartown Pizza

Location: 224 Edgartown Road

In the heart of Edgartown, this pizzeria is a great spot for grabbing a quick and satisfying meal. Edgartown Pizza offers a wide variety of toppings and styles, ensuring there’s something for everyone. Their crust is notably light and chewy, a perfect base for both classic and creative toppings. Edgartown Pizza is known for its welcoming team, affordable prices, and, most notably, its tasty cuisine!

5. Offshore Ale Co

Location: Offshore Ale Co. is conveniently located at 30 Kennebec Ave. in downtown Oak Bluffs, steps from Circuit Avenue,  Ocean Park, the Steamship Authority ferry terminal, and Oak Bluffs harbor.

Established in 1997, Offshore Ale Co has become a staple for both locals and visitors of Martha’s Vineyard, offering satisfying meals, top-notch craft beers, and a welcoming community vibe. As the island’s premier brewpub, Offshore provides both lunch and dinner every day throughout the year. The menu features classic brewpub fare such as fish and chips and steamed mussels, alongside specialty thin-crust pizzas and sophisticated seafood dishes. With nine beer taps that change with the seasons, showcasing around twenty different styles, there is a brew to suit everyone’s taste.

6. Chilmark General Store

Location: 7 State Rd, Chilmark, MA 02535

At Chilmark General Store, the pizza-making process is a true labor of love. Each pizza is crafted with precision, blending traditional techniques with a dash of local flavor. The dough is hand-stretched and topped with fresh, high-quality ingredients, ensuring a delightful experience in every bite. Whether one craves a classic cheese or something more adventurous, the pizzas are baked to perfection, offering a slice of Chilmark in every piece.

7. Slice of Edgartown

Location: 22 Dock St Edgartown, MA 02539

A newer addition to the island’s pizza scene, Slice of Edgartown quickly gained popularity for its creative toppings and excellent service. Located in downtown Edgartown, it’s an ideal stop during a day of shopping or before heading to the nearby beaches. 

8. Bobby B's Restaurant & Bakery

Location: 22 Main Street Vineyard Haven

Bobby B's merges the cozy atmosphere of a family-style restaurant with the delights of a bakery, featuring a menu highlighted by scrumptious pizzas. Renowned for their thick, chewy crusts topped with a hearty blend of cheeses, Bobby B's creates a warm setting ideal for family dining. The restaurant offers happy hour specials, and caters to vegetarian preferences.

9. Island Fresh Pizza & Subs

Location: 395 State Rd Vineyard Haven

Island Fresh Pizza & Subs specializes in crafting a wide array of mouth-watering dishes, serving up fresh and hot Pizza, Subs, Burgers, Calzones, Quesadillas, Paninis, Wraps, and Salads, among other tasty options. Each dish is made with high-quality, locally sourced ingredients, ensuring every bite is as fresh as it is flavorful. Whether you're in the mood for a gooey, cheese-filled calzone, a hearty sub, or a light, crisp salad, Island Fresh offers something to satisfy every palate. With a commitment to providing delicious meals in a friendly and welcoming environment, it’s the perfect spot for a quick lunch or a casual dinner.

10. Bad Martha Beer

Location: Edgartown

Bad Martha Beer is not just a brewery but a local favorite that brings together craft beer enthusiasts and pizza lovers. Located in Edgartown, this spot is known for its laid-back atmosphere and community-focused vibe. While primarily celebrated for its unique range of craft beers, Bad Martha also offers a selection of artisan pizzas. These pizzas are the perfect complement to their beers, featuring locally sourced ingredients and inventive toppings.

11. Orange Peel Bakery

Located at 682 State Road, Aquinnah, MA, Orange Peel Bakery is a local favorite for pizza lovers. Open from April to November, the bakery hosts pizza nights on Thursdays and Fridays from 12 noon to 7 PM, and Saturdays from 12 noon to 3 PM. Here, everyone is welcome to join the fun, create their own pizza, and enjoy it fresh from the stone oven. It’s not just about food; it’s about community and making connections. All pizza enthusiasts are encouraged to stop by and enjoy the atmosphere. For the latest updates, check out their Instagram @orangepeelbakery.

No matter where you find yourself on Martha's Vineyard, a great pizza isn't far away. Each of these spots offers something unique, ensuring that whether you're in the mood for a classic slice or a gourmet pie, you'll find something to satisfy your cravings. So next time you visit, make sure to stop by one (or more) of these top pizza places and taste the best of what Martha's Vineyard has to offer.